Flavors

RETIRED FLAVORS

Our signature sweet & salty dough baked soft & thick, with lots of semi-sweet chocolate mixed in. This recipe is newly revised: now with crispier edges with the same soft middle you love!

Your childhood breakfast turned cookie! This cookie is our secret recipe but what we WILL tell you… it tastes just like a pop-tart. Stuffed with strawberry jam and topped with while chocolate and a bite size pop-tart.

A soft, sweet lemon cookie with lots of white chocolate chips mixed in. Topped with a sugar coated lemon candy.

“Cookies n cream” meet peanut butter! A soft, rich, and fudgey peanut butter cookie with lots of crushed Oreos.

NEW - A thick brownie-like chocolate cookie topped with chocolate buttercream and rolled in chocolate sprinkles and mint chips.

🔥S’MORES SAMMIE
Our classic sweet and salty dough base sandwiched with marshmallow buttercream and creamy Nutella. Rolled in crushed graham cracker for the perfect s’mores sandwich cookie experience.

The softest sugar cookie you’ll ever meet, with warm vanilla flavor and rolled in festive Valentine sprinkles.

Our signature sweet & salty dough baked soft & thick - minus the semi-sweet chocolate - this classic brown sugar cookie is NAKED.

A light cocoa base, with a smooth and cake-y taste. Stuffed with cream cheese butter cream and topped with a white chocolate heart.

A rich and smooth peanut butter cookie stuffed with hazelnut cocoa spread (Nutella) and topped with a Herseys kiss.

Inspired by a favorite Valentine treat; chocolate covered strawberries. A thick brownie-like chocolate cookie topped with strawberry buttercream and rolled in chocolate sprinkles.

An orange sugar cookie with "bengal" striped milk and white chocolate drizzle.

Introducing an impromptu Peanut Buddy 2.0🧡
The rich soft peanut butter cookie you know and love but now with candied peanuts (rather than peanut butter candies - see that happy accident?? 😂). & of course stuffed with a scoop of creamy peanut butter.

A cake batter cookie with crushed golden Oreos, topped with cake batter buttercream, and rolled in rainbow sprinkles. Each cookie comes with a birthday cake candle so you can celebrate with us!

A rich peanut butter cookie with Reeses pieces candy, stuffed with a scoop of creamy peanut butter

A rich chocolate chocolate cookie with lots of semi sweet chocolate, baked to perfection for a fudge-like taste. (Best when served heated!)

The softest sugar cookie you’ll ever meet, with warm vanilla flavor and rolled in rainbow sprinkles

Our signature sweet & salty dough baked soft & thick, with lots of semi-sweet chocolate mixed in.

The Christmas Menu

A rich chocolate cookie made with Swiss Miss™️ Hot Chocolate and semi-sweet chips. Loaded with white chocolate drizzle, mini marshmallows, and crushed peppermint.

A soft cinnamon sugar cookie topped with a thick layer of cream cheese buttercream and rolled in cinnamon sugar.

Our rich peanut butter cookie recipe you know and love with red and green m&m’s™️ and, filled with grandma’s Christmas peanut butter fudge!

The softest sugar cookie you’ll ever meet. Sweet, dense, and rich in vanilla, rolled in festive Christmas sprinkles.

Our signature sweet & salty dough baked soft & thick, with lots of semi-sweet chocolate mixed in.

Mad Batter Cookie Co. is a Home Bakery operating under Ohio's Cottage Food Law. Special food allergen caution; most equipment will contact nut, egg, and dairy products that may not be listed on the ingredient card. Cross contact may occur.

Registration issued by the State of Ohio and Meigs County.