The Vintage Menu
WEDDING CAKE
An almond sugar cookie topped with almond buttercream. Just like the classic traditional wedding cakes!
NUTS & BOLTS
Paying homage to Racine Hardware where we first started selling cookies in stores (and to the Owner who appreciates tradition as much as we do)! This is a peanut butter cookie with lots of m&m’s and pretzels.
OATMEAL RAISIN
A soft cinnamon oatmeal raisin cookie with lots of raisins, just like grandma used to make!
PUMPKIN ROLL
A pumpkin spice cookie topped with vanilla buttercream and cinnamon sugar.
CLASSIC CHOCOLATE CHIP
Our signature salty and sweet dough with lots of semi sweet chocolate chips. Based on my mom’s original recipe!
How it works
JOIN THE CLUB! Never miss a menu
- Subscribe to Mad Batter's Cookie Club
We're now offering a 6-pack subscription box! Delivered to your door every month with no worries of missing a menu drop. - Exclusive Flavors
Not only will you get the 5 monthly flavors, but we're adding an exclusive, subscriber only flavor you won't find anywhere else. - Sit back and enjoy
Did we mention these arrive right to your doorstep? Chill your favorite milk and call your cookie lovin' friends for a taste test party.
Follow The Fun
Our customers love us
-
Shelly Batten
Absolutely hands down THE best cookies ever!!
-
Tori Bishop
Once I tried one I was hooked! Each cookie is beautifully packaged and presented. The flavors range from traditional too unique. Not one I chose disappointed to the point I’m not sure if I could choose a favorite. They each blew my mind with how much I enjoyed them. The new menus will keep me coming back for more as I can’t wait to see what’s coming next!
-
Alyss Well
We received some cookies as a gift this year! They are AMAZING. Literally everything you want in a cookie. Ooeygooey center, crisp sides, thick, and the most AMAZING flavors! Yum! Ours were demolished in seconds!
-
Brittany Young
These cookies go above and beyond my expectations of what a cookie should taste like! They are as thick as they are round, the flavor is extraordinary and I can tell this small company owner really puts her heart into this. Will be ordering more!
-
Thomas Karr
Everybody there is awesome and their cookies are awesome!!
-
Lauren DeLancey
Found these cookies at the Meigs County Farmers Market… they are amazing and one of a kind!! Can’t wait to see what they come up with next! If you think you want to try a cookie flavor don’t question just do it before it gets “retired.” Thanks for great cookies!
-
K Baumgarnder
I was visiting Columbus and bought a corn bread cookie from you at Dublin Market and its literally one of the best cookies I’ve ever had. 10/10 definitely the best cornbread cookie out there.
