The Original Menu! (Baking all of May)
CLASSIC CHOCOLATE CHIP
Inspired by my mom’s original recipe, a salty and sweet base with lots of semi sweet chocolate chips
SUGAR MAMA
The softest sugar cookie you’ll ever eat, with rainbow sprinkles of course
PEANUT BUDDY
A rich peanut butter cookie with lots of reese’s pieces and stuffed with homemade peanut butter fudge
BROWNIE BATTER
A brownie-like cookie with lots of semi sweet chocolate chips
PRO TIP: Heat this cookie 8-12 seconds in the microwave for the perfect texture
CINNA-DOODLE
A soft cinnamon cookie topped with cinnamon buttercream and rolled in cinnamon sugar… did I mention cinnamon?
How it works
Never miss a menu
- Subscribe to Mad Batter
We're now offering a 6-pack subscription box! Delivered to your door every month with no worries of missing a menu drop. - Exclusive Flavors
Not only will you get the 5 monthly flavors, but we're adding an exclusive, subscriber only flavor you won't find anywhere else. - Sit back and enjoy
Did we mention these arrive right to your doorstep? Chill your favorite milk and call your cookie lovin' friends for a taste test party.
Follow The Fun
Our customers love us
-
Shelly Batten
Absolutely hands down THE best cookies ever!!
-
Tori Bishop
Once I tried one I was hooked! Each cookie is beautifully packaged and presented. The flavors range from traditional too unique. Not one I chose disappointed to the point I’m not sure if I could choose a favorite. They each blew my mind with how much I enjoyed them. The new menus will keep me coming back for more as I can’t wait to see what’s coming next!
-
Alyss Well
We received some cookies as a gift this year! They are AMAZING. Literally everything you want in a cookie. Ooeygooey center, crisp sides, thick, and the most AMAZING flavors! Yum! Ours were demolished in seconds!
-
Brittany Young
These cookies go above and beyond my expectations of what a cookie should taste like! They are as thick as they are round, the flavor is extraordinary and I can tell this small company owner really puts her heart into this. Will be ordering more!
-
Thomas Karr
Everybody there is awesome and their cookies are awesome!!
-
Lauren DeLancey
Found these cookies at the Meigs County Farmers Market… they are amazing and one of a kind!! Can’t wait to see what they come up with next! If you think you want to try a cookie flavor don’t question just do it before it gets “retired.” Thanks for great cookies!
-
K Baumgarnder
I was visiting Columbus and bought a corn bread cookie from you at Dublin Market and its literally one of the best cookies I’ve ever had. 10/10 definitely the best cornbread cookie out there.
